Will Moth Balls Really Keep Deer Away?

Wildlife & Nature
1

I’ve been struggling to keep deer out of my garden, and I’ve heard some people mention using mothballs as a deterrent.

Here’s what I’m wondering:

  • Effectiveness: Do mothballs actually work to repel deer?
  • Safety: Is it safe to use mothballs around plants and wildlife?
  • Alternatives: Are there other methods that might be more effective or safer?

I want to maintain my garden without damaging the environment or harming any wildlife. Any tips from those who have tried this or have other suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance for your advice!

2

I’ve heard mixed results about using moth balls to deter deer. Some people swear by them, while others claim they don’t work at all. Has anyone had consistent success?

3

From my experience, they worked for a short while. I noticed deer stopped coming around for a month or so, but then they returned. I think they might get used to the smell!

5 Likes
4

Using moth balls to deter deer? That’s an interesting approach! I’ve never tried it but would love to hear more about the science behind it. Are there any studies?

3 Likes
5

I’ve read a few articles suggesting that moth balls can be effective due to the strong smell. However, they might only repel deer temporarily, as they can adapt to the scents over time.

6

Exactly! It seems like the effectiveness can vary depending on the deer and the area. Maybe combining them with other deterrents could help?

7

I tried using moth balls last summer, and they kept the deer away for a good while! I think placing them strategically around my garden helped. Just don’t forget to replace them regularly!

8 Likes
8

That’s great to hear! Do you think the placement made a significant difference?

9

I’ve had a mixed bag of results with moth balls. Sometimes they keep deer away, but I’ve seen them ignore the scent after a while. It’s like they have a scent memory or something!

10

If moth balls don’t work, has anyone tried other alternatives like predator urine or plants that deer dislike? I want to explore all my options!

11

I tried predator urine, and it helped for a bit, but I found it very strong-smelling. It was like my garden turned into a wild animal sanctuary!

12

Definitely! I placed mine at the entrance of the garden and near favorite plants. Every little bit helps!

13

I kind of feel like we should just ask the deer what they dislike! Maybe they hate noisy wind chimes. Have you ever thought of that?

14

Haha, that would be funny! Imagine a deer running away from some wind chimes! But seriously, creative ideas are always welcome.

15

I’ve got to say, I think moth balls can work as part of a larger strategy. They can be a deterrent, but they really shouldn’t be the only line of defense.

4 Likes
16

Totally agree! Combining different deterrents might make our gardens less appealing to deer overall.

17

I appreciate everyone’s feedback! It’s a challenge finding what truly works. Whether it’s moth balls or something else, it’s good to hear different experiences. Thanks for sharing!

18

I’ve heard that moth balls can be effective, but they’re not the only option. Commercial sprays specifically designed for deer often work better, and they usually have a pleasant scent.

19

That’s true! Moth balls can deter many animals, but they are quite toxic and could be dangerous around pets and kids. Have you considered natural remedies like garlic or hot pepper spray?

20

Natural remedies sound appealing! They tend to be safer for the environment, and I hear they don’t smell as bad as moth balls! Has anyone tried those?