What's the Difference: 9x18 Makarov vs 9mm?

Gun & Shooting
1

I’ve been doing some research on ammunition, especially around the 9x18 Makarov and the 9mm, and I would love to get some opinions from experienced shooters here.

Performance Comparison

  • Ballistics: How do the ballistics of 9x18 Makarov differ from 9mm? I’ve heard the 9mm generally has better velocity and energy.
  • Recoil: Is there a significant difference in recoil when shooting both types?

Suitability for Firearms

  • Firearm Compatibility: Which firearms are more suitable for each caliber? I’m particularly interested in both handguns and possible rifles.
  • Availability: How does the availability of each ammunition type affect their practicality for everyday use?

Applications

  • Self-Defense: Based on your experience, which caliber would you recommend for self-defense purposes?
  • Shooting Sports: If you participate in shooting competitions, does one caliber have an edge over the other?

Any insights, experiences, or recommended resources would be greatly appreciated! Thanks!

2

The key difference between 9x18 Makarov and 9mm is in their ballistic performance. The 9mm typically offers higher velocity and energy levels, making it potentially more effective for self-defense situations.

6 Likes
3

That’s a great point! The 9x18 Makarov, while not as powerful, can be more manageable for some shooters due to its lower recoil.

4

In terms of terminal ballistics, the 9mm typically expands more effectively due to its higher velocity and a wider range of projectile options, which makes it popular for personal defense.

1 Like
5

Exactly! Also, the availability of +P ammunition for 9mm enhances its effectiveness significantly compared to the Makarov.

6

However, the 9x18 can still be effective in close-quarters situations where penetration is necessary, as it can perform well against barriers in a pinch.

7

That’s true! I would say both cartridges have their merits; it really depends on the intended use and user preference.

8

From experience, I’ve found that the 9mm feels faster and hits harder, especially with full metal jacket rounds in a self-defense scenario.

9

Haha, true! But I’ve seen some shooters prefer the Makarov for its nostalgic feel and classic design, which can’t be ignored!

10

Supporters of the Makarov often cite its simplicity and reliability, which shouldn’t be overlooked when considering a carry option.

11

Absolutely! And it’s usually considered a good choice for those new to shooting due to its manageable recoil.

8 Likes
12

How does the recoil of both calibers really compare in practice? I’ve heard mixed opinions on that.

13

From my experience, the 9x18 has less felt recoil, making it easier to manage for new shooters. But 9mm is more versatile overall!

14

This discussion really makes me think about my choices for home defense. Balancing power and control is essential, isn’t it?

15

Definitely! Each user’s comfort and confidence in their choice is what ultimately makes the difference.

16

It’s interesting how opinions diverge on both cartridges. Both have their advocates, but I wonder if there’s a clear winner, or if it just depends on the shooter.

17

I’m curious about the practical differences between firearms chambered in 9x18 Makarov and 9mm. Are there significant pros and cons to each?

8 Likes
18

Great question! The 9mm is widely regarded as more popular and available, especially in terms of guns and ammo options. On the other hand, the 9x18 Makarov is unique and has fewer modern firearms chambered for it.

19

Most people find that the 9mm has a larger selection of both firearms and ammunition. Brands like Glock and Sig Sauer dominate the market for 9mm, while Makarov options are limited to a few models.

20

That makes sense! But I’ve heard some cool things about Makarov firearms, especially their build quality. Anyone have experiences with those?