What's the Best Metal for Knife Making?

Resources & Tools
1

Seeking Advice on Knife Making Materials

I’m diving into the world of knife making and I’m really trying to identify the best metal for making knives—specifically for outdoor purposes like camping and hiking. I know there are various types of steel out there and I’m a bit overwhelmed by the options.

Here’s what I’m looking for:

  • Durability: The knife should withstand outdoor conditions.
  • Ease of sharpening: Since I’ll be out in the wild, I’ll need something that can be easily sharpened on the go.
  • Corrosion resistance: It would be great to have a metal that can resist rust, especially if I’m near water.
  • Budget-friendly options: As a beginner, I’d like to know about affordable options or even using scrap materials.

Specific Questions:

  1. Which types of steel are recommended for beginners?
  2. Are there any particular brands or products that are known for good quality?
  3. What do you all use for handle materials? Do you have any tips for sourcing these?
  4. Is there a significant difference between stainless steel and high carbon steel for field use?

Additional Thoughts

I’ve seen a lot of threads online discussing different steels like 1084, D2, and 440C. If anyone has experience with these or recommendations based on personal experience, I’d love to hear about them!

Thanks in advance for your help. Looking forward to your insights!

1 Like
2

When it comes to knife making, high carbon steel is often praised for its edge retention and ease of sharpening. It’s the go-to for many traditionalists. However, it does require maintenance to prevent rusting.

6 Likes
3

Absolutely! I love high carbon steel knives. They can hold a great edge, but I find the rusting to be quite the hassle sometimes.

4

I personally prefer stainless steel for outdoor or kitchen knives. It’s durable and resistant to corrosion! It might sacrifice some edge retention compared to high carbon steel, but it’s low maintenance.

5

That’s true! Stainless steel is like the dependable friend you can rely on in tough situations, but do you find it hard to sharpen?

6

Tool steels can also be a fantastic option! They offer great edge retention and toughness. Just keep in mind they can be trickier to sharpen, especially the harder varieties.

5 Likes
7

Very good point! Some tool steels like D2 are incredibly tough but can be a pain to sharpen. It’s a trade-off!

8

What are everyone’s thoughts on CPM steel? I’ve heard it balances edge retention and corrosion resistance well, but I’m curious about sharpening. Anyone have experience?

9

CPM steels are fantastic! They can hold an edge super well and sharpen quite comfortably. Just slightly on the expensive side.

4 Likes
10

I think it also depends on what you plan to use the knife for. For instance, if you’re going to use it in a wet environment, stainless might be best, while for fine slicing, a high carbon steel could be ideal.

11

Excellent point! You wouldn’t want a high carbon knife when prepping for oysters, right? Rust city!

4 Likes
12

Yeah, I mean not everyone wants to babysit their knives! It’s all about finding the right balance for your needs. Sometimes I stick with simpler steels to avoid the fuss.

13

Preach! But on the flip side, there’s something really satisfying about maintaining a beautiful high carbon knife.

14

I wonder how many knifemakers have wished home maintenance was included in their business plan. :joy: Anyone else think it’s ironic? Just me?

15

Reflecting on the conversation, it seems every steel type has its lovers and haters. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and intended use. What a unique world of choices!

16

When it comes to knife making, heat treatment is crucial! Quenching and tempering can significantly affect your knife’s performance. For example, quenching can increase hardness but may make the blade brittle if not tempered properly.

17

Absolutely! It’s like magic how the right heat treatment can turn a soft metal into a hard tool. But be careful—if you overdo it, you end up with a very sharp paperweight!

2 Likes
18

I’ve always found that oil quenching tends to give better toughness compared to water. Anyone else have preferences on quenching media? It can really alter the outcome!

19

Great point! I’ve used both, and I agree, oil can be more forgiving. Has anyone tried plate quenching? I’ve heard it has its advantages too.

20

For tempering, I usually go for a low temperature around 350°F, which helps balance hardness and toughness well. Too high, and you risk losing that edge!