Deciding between a sit on top kayak and a sit in kayak can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re new to kayaking or looking to upgrade. Each type offers its own set of advantages and disadvantages that cater to different kayaking experiences. In this post, I’m hoping to gather some insights and personal experiences to help make my choice a bit easier.
Comparisons and Considerations
Here, I’ll break down some key points people often consider when choosing between the two:
Comfort & Storage
Sit on Top Kayaks: These kayaks are generally more open and provide easier access for getting in and out. This is quite beneficial for activities like fishing or quick beach landings since you don’t have to worry about crawling into a cramped space. However, without walls, I find there might be less security if you go overboard.
Sit in Kayaks: Perfect for colder waters or rougher conditions. They have a more enclosed design which can keep you dryer and warmer. But, the seating can be less comfortable for longer trips, and getting in can require more flexibility.
Performance & Stability
Sit on Top Kayaks: Great for beginners due to their inherent stability. They are hard to tip over and offer a fun, relaxing experience as you can easily jump off for a swim. On the downside, they can be slower and may not handle as well in rough water.
Sit in Kayaks: Typically favored by seasoned paddlers, they offer better tracking and speed, especially in choppy waters. The cockpit design allows for lower center of gravity, enhancing balance and control.
Accessibility & Use
Sit on Top Kayaks: If you’re looking to kayak in warm weather or enjoy activities like fishing, a sit on top might be your best option since it’s easier to move around and re-enter after a swim.
Sit in Kayaks: Ideal for longer expeditions or adventures in unpredictable weather. They also tend to have more storage space for longer trips, which is crucial if you plan to kayak for hours or even overnight.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between a sit on top and sit in kayak depends on your needs, paddling style, and the type of waters you’ll be navigating. I’m particularly interested to hear from those of you who have experienced both types. What do you value most? Is comfort more important, or is the kayak’s performance in rough waters your main concern?
Any recommendations or insights you can share would be greatly appreciated!
I’ve always found sit-on-top kayaks more comfortable, especially in warm weather. You can move around more easily and stay cool. But in rough waters, they certainly feel less stable than sit-in kayaks.
That’s a good point! I love how sit-on-top kayaks make it easier to get in and out. However, I think sit-in kayaks provide better protection against waves.
Comfort-wise, the seating position in sit-in kayaks is often more cushioned and supportive, which is great for longer paddling sessions. But for beginners, sit-on-top kayaks are usually more user-friendly.
While stability is essential, I feel like sit-in kayaks give me a sense of being one with the water. I’ve had great experiences kayaking in them, especially in windy conditions.
Totally agree, Susan! And I think it’s important to consider the type of water you’re paddling in. In calm lakes, either type works, but in the ocean, I’d lean towards sit-in for the added stability.
I’ve transitioned from a sit-on-top to a sit-in kayak recently, and the difference in comfort during long trips is noticeable! But I do miss the ease of getting in and out.
I think it really depends on what you plan to do. Sit-on-top kayaks are perfect for fishing and hot weather since you can easily get in and out. But sit-in kayaks are great for touring as they provide more protection from the elements.
For recreational paddling, I prefer sit-in kayaks. They track better in windy conditions and keep you drier. Plus, they usually have more storage space for a day trip.
That’s a good point, lucas74! I had to learn the hard way about how much wind can affect a sit-on-top kayak. It can be a workout just to keep it straight!
I think both types have their place. If you’re planning to paddle in rough waters or cooler weather, definitely opt for a sit-in. They are less affected by waves and offer better insulation.
If you’re into touring or longer paddling trips, sit-in kayaks really shine. They allow you to pack more gear and are far more comfortable on multi-day excursions.