Marlin makes some solid .45-70 lever actions. You get that classic feel with modern reliability!
4 Likes
I really enjoy the .50 Alaskan for its power, but .45-70 ammo is widely available, which is a big plus if you plan to practice a lot.
It’s important to think about cost too. Affordable ammo for the .45-70 definitely helps if you’re going to the range often!
That’s true! Plus, the .45-70 has a great reputation for versatility on game.
2 Likes
For someone just starting, I’d lean toward the .45-70. Easier recoil and a forgiving caliber for beginners.
From a historical perspective, the .45-70 is fun due to its long history with hunters. It’s like using a piece of the past.
1 Like
Honestly, both have their merits. But I’ll always argue the .50 Alaskan feels like firing a cannon! What’s not to love? Haha!
I’ve been using both .50 Alaskan and .45-70 for hunting. In terms of factory ammo, .45-70 is much easier to find, while .50 Alaskan can be a challenge. Reloads offer better options for both, but you’ll find more .45-70 components available.
That’s true! I also enjoy handloading. The .50 Alaskan lets you customize your loads, maximizing its potential. Just be mindful of pressures when working up loads!
.45-70 has the benefit of numerous resources online for handloading. Has anyone tried both? If so, how do you feel they compare in the field during hunts?
I’ve used both and prefer .45-70 for closer shots and heavier game. The .50 Alaskan shines on bigger animals due to its stopping power.
8 Likes
I agree with mitchellblanchard. The .50 Alaskan is a beast for stopping power. But let’s not forget about the recoil; it’s significant! Handloading allows you to adjust that, making it more manageable.
Does anyone have tips on sourcing brass for the .50 Alaskan? I find it a bit hard to come by, compared to .45-70 which is almost everywhere.
Yes, getting brass for the .50 Alaskan can be a hassle. Have you tried online retailers? Sometimes you can find great deals on brass there.
For handloading, I recommend investing in a good set of dies for both cartridges. Having quality dies makes a notable difference. What grain weights do you all prefer for each caliber?
Absolutely! I’ve been fond of the 350 grain for .45-70, but for .50 Alaskan, I usually stick to 500 grain for big game!
Sounds like a heavyweight battle! Is there a significant difference in trajectory between the two cartridges? I’ve heard mixed opinions.
6 Likes
Most definitely! The .45-70 drops a bit more than the .50 Alaskan, but it also depends on the load used. Balancing load and range makes a big difference.
7 Likes
As a newbie, it sounds like I need a lot more practice with both! Thanks for all the insights, everyone. Handloading seems like a science in itself!