Exactly! Plus, the .454 is lighter, which is a bonus for those long hikes in the field.
I’ve seen folks joke about the .500 S&W being a ‘hand cannon,’ but that’s exactly why I love it—the power! Just make sure you can handle the recoil!
That is true! The first time I shot a .500, I thought I was going to lose my arm! But it sure packs a punch against big game.
5 Likes
I lean towards the .500 for self-defense against large predators. The ballistics and stopping power are impressive, especially in dangerous wildlife situations.
1 Like
That’s a solid point. However, in terms of sport shooting, the .454 might be the more enjoyable option!
I believe practice is key, regardless of the caliber. Both options deserve respect and shouldn’t be underestimated in the field. Ideally, try both if you can!
Great advice! It’s not just about caliber; your comfort and accuracy with the firearm should be the most important factor in your choice.
7 Likes
Ultimately, it seems to come down to personal preference and intended use. Maybe a friendly competition between the two calibers would settle the debate!
When considering the availability of ammo, .454 Casull is generally less common in stores compared to .500 S&W. You might find shooting the .500 more manageable budget-wise, especially if you’re planning frequent trips for practice.
That’s a good point, but I find the .454 Casull has a niche market that sometimes offers great deals. It’s worth checking online suppliers for bulk purchases.
Both calibers can be pricey, but local factors can hugely influence this. Depending on your location, one may be cheaper than the other, so it’s good to shop around.
It’s true, but in my experience, .500 S&W offers more consistent availability thanks to its popularity in big game hunting circles.
Agreed! Availability is one thing, but if you love shooting, consider it a hobby investment. Ammo cost shouldn’t entirely deter you from the .454.
What are the typical prices you’re seeing for both calibers? I’ve heard .500 can be quite a bit more expensive.
For .500 S&W, it’s usually around $1.50 to $3 per round. The .454 Casull can range from $1 to $2 per round, but prices fluctuate based on location and demand.
Wow, that’s a significant difference in cost. Makes you think twice about the frequency of practice sessions.
Exactly! I often opt for reloading my own ammo to mitigate costs. It allows me to shoot more often without breaking the bank.
5 Likes
Reloading is a great option, but not everyone has the time or inclination. Plus initial setup costs can be a hurdle too.
True! I guess it also depends on how often you shoot and your overall budget for hunting and practice.
And let’s not forget the joy of shooting. Sometimes the experience means more than the price tag.
4 Likes