Looking for the Best Fishing Guides in Islamorada!

Fishing
1

I’m planning a trip to Islamorada soon, and I want to make the most of my fishing experience while I’m there. I’ve heard that it’s one of the top places for fishing in Florida, but I’m not sure who to book a guide with.

What I’m Looking For

I’m interested in:

  • Charter Services: Ideally, I’d like a guide who knows the best spots and can help me catch some big fish!
  • Expert Advice: Tips from local guides about the best times to fish, what tackle to use, and any specific techniques that work well in the area.
  • Pricing & Availability: Knowing what to expect in terms of cost and how to book these services in advance.

Questions:

  1. Who are the top-rated fishing guides you’ve personally used?
  2. What should I look for in a fishing guide?
  3. Is it better to go for a half-day or full-day charter for the best experience?

I’m really excited about this trip and any insights or experiences you could share would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance for your help!

2

If you want a great experience, I highly recommend Captain Joe’s Fishing Charters. He specializes in tarpon and has fantastic customer service! We had an unforgettable day on the water.

8 Likes
3

That sounds awesome! Have you fished with him recently? I’m looking to plan a trip soon.

8 Likes
4

I second Captain Joe! We caught a ton of fish. His enthusiasm makes the trip even more enjoyable. Plus, he shares some great fishing tips.

5

I’ve used several guides in Islamorada. Captain Mike’s Charter Service focuses on sport fishing. He was knowledgeable but a bit pricey.

6

I’ve heard mixed reviews about him. Was your experience generally good, though?

7

I had a fantastic time with Captain Amy! She’s really patient and helps with everything, especially if you’re new to fishing.

8

Captain Amy sounds like a great choice! Does she cater to larger groups, or is it more one-on-one?

4 Likes
9

I need that! It’s been years since I fished. How did you find her?

10

We booked her through a recommendation from a friend. She’s well-known around town for her tutorials. Highly recommend her!

11

Does anyone have funny stories from their trips? I once had a seagull steal my bait right off the line! I laughed so hard.

12

Hi everyone! If you’re looking for the best fishing guides in Islamorada, I highly recommend checking out the ones specializing in tarpon fishing. They have some amazing techniques that really improve your chances of a catch!

13

I totally agree! Tarpon fishing is fantastic there. I’ve had great luck with guides who combine live baiting and fly fishing for tarpon. Makes for an exciting day!

4 Likes
14

What other species can we target while in Islamorada? I’ve heard that reef fishing can also be quite rewarding.

15

Absolutely! Many guides also focus on snapper and grouper fishing around the reefs. It’s a different vibe, but a lot of fun too! Bring your A-game for the bigger fish!

16

I’ve heard the same! Does anyone have recommendations for guides who are strong in offshore fishing as well?

8 Likes
17

One guide that comes to mind is Captain Mike. He’s known for targeting mahi-mahi and Wahoo. Offshore is where the adventure is, but remember to take seasickness medication just in case!

18

Thanks for the tip! I can’t wait to experience the excitement of targeting Wahoo! Any specific techniques to keep in mind?

19

When chasing Wahoo, fast trolling with lures can be very effective. Just keep a close eye on your rods! It’s the thrill of the chase that makes it so memorable.

6 Likes
20

Sounds intense! How do the guides typically handle these kinds of fish? I imagine it takes a lot of skill.

8 Likes