12 Gauge vs 20 Gauge Recoil: Which One Should I Choose?

I’m really curious to understand the differences in recoil between the 12 gauge and 20 gauge shotguns. I’ve been considering which one to choose for my hunting and clay shooting activities, and recoil is a big factor for me.

Why Does Recoil Matter?

Recoil is often one of the most unpleasant aspects of shooting, especially for those of us who may not have the upper body strength to manage heavier kicks. Understanding how different gauges affect recoil can help in making an informed choice between the 12 gauge and the 20 gauge shotguns.

Key Comparisons

  • 12 Gauge:

    • Larger shells, typically resulting in more payload and more shot per trigger pull.
    • Generally produces more recoil due to the increased power.
    • Great for larger game hunting, but may not be suitable for newcomers or those sensitive to recoil.
  • 20 Gauge:

    • Smaller shells which tend to produce less recoil compared to 12 gauge.
    • Great for hunting smaller game or for situations where a lighter load is preferred.
    • Easier to manage for those who may be recoil sensitive or new shooters.

Personal Experience

From my own experience, the 12 gauge did feel a bit more powerful, but I found myself flinching and not getting accurate shots off. Switching to a 20 gauge made my shooting practice much more enjoyable. Plus, I was able to shoot longer without discomfort.

Conclusion

In choosing between a 12 gauge and a 20 gauge shotgun, consider the type of shooting you’ll be doing and how much recoil you’re comfortable handling. If you’re primarily hunting smaller game or want something more manageable, the 20 gauge might be the best fit. If you need heavier firepower for larger animals and are prepared to handle the recoil, the 12 gauge could be your go-to.

I’d love to know what others think about this! What have your experiences been? Are there any specific brands or models you would recommend for either gauge? Let’s share our thoughts and help each other out!

7 Likes

I’ve shot both gauges, and the recoil difference is significant. The 12 gauge kicks much harder, which can be uncomfortable for some, especially those who are new to shotgunning.

Absolutely! I’ve found that the 20 gauge is much easier on the shoulder, allowing for longer shooting sessions without fatigue.

Statistically, the 20 gauge has about 30% less felt recoil than the 12 gauge. This not only improves comfort but can enhance accuracy for many shooters.

1 Like

While I agree, keep in mind that the type of shell and load can also affect recoil. Sometimes, a lighter load in a 12 gauge feels similar to a heavier 20 gauge.

That’s interesting! I’ve always preferred the 12 gauge for its versatility, but I guess recoil does make a difference in extended use.

1 Like

As someone who has a bit of a shoulder injury, I definitely feel the difference in recoil. The 20 gauge allows me to shoot comfortably without hurting myself.

I started with a 12 gauge, and although it was fun, I switched to a 20 gauge after a few outings. Way less sore the next day!

Just make sure to consider what you’ll be using the shotgun for. For casual shooting, a 20 gauge might be perfect, but for hunting larger game, a 12 could be necessary.

That’s a valid point! I primarily bird hunt, and the 20 gauge suits me just fine for that.

2 Likes

This may sound silly, but I enjoy the feeling of the kick from the 12 gauge. It adds a bit of excitement! But I totally understand why others would prefer the 20 gauge.

Not silly at all! It’s all about what feels good and fun for you.

I suppose it depends on individual tolerance too. Some people can handle more recoil and actually prefer it for the greater stopping power.

2 Likes

Recoil is a major factor when choosing between 12 and 20 gauge. The 12 gauge has more punch, which can be great for hunting larger game but intimidating for beginners. The 20 gauge offers a softer recoil, making it easier for new shooters.

That’s a great point, Michael! I’ve found that 20 gauge is perfect for sport shooting sessions, especially during extended practice. Less recoil means I can focus more on accuracy.

Recoil also varies based on the load you choose. A lighter load in a 12 gauge can mitigate some of the recoil while still providing power for self-defense. Anyone experience with that?

4 Likes

Yes! I often use reduced recoil ammo in my 12 gauge for home defense. It helps me maintain control while still having the necessary stopping power.

From my experience, if you’re hunting small game or birds, a 20 gauge is ideal. Less recoil means quicker follow-up shots. But for big game, the 12 gauge just can’t be beaten.

True that! The stopping power is crucial there. However, it’s worth noting that a smaller frame shooter might find a 20 gauge more manageable overall.

I think skill level plays a big role. Newer shooters might feel overwhelmed by 12 gauge recoil. Starting with a 20 can build confidence before moving up.